Tackling Inequalities in Cancer Screening Uptake

Challenge

Half of the population will experience cancer during their lifetime, yet approximately 40% of these cases are preventable, equating to over 135,000 cases each year. Early diagnosis is crucial for effective treatment. A national healthcare plan set an ambitious target for 75% of cancer patients to be diagnosed at an early stage by 2028.
A key target for early diagnosis is cervical cancer. Despite 99.8% of cervical cancer cases being preventable, it still causes around 1000 deaths a year in the UK. Caja was hired to assist with business operations in designing behavioural science nudges to enhance the uptake for cervical screening, and to pilot this approach within primary care providers.

Solution

Stakeholder Engagement
Caja conducted stakeholder workshops - both in-person before the pandemic and virtually after restrictions were applied - aimed at:
  • Increasing awareness of behavioural science as a tool for demand and change management, enhancing capabilities across the system.
  • Understanding ongoing initiatives to improve screening uptake, ensuring the firm's efforts complemented and extended existing projects.
  • Piloting nudge design and implementation in real settings.
These efforts were complemented by interviews and engagement across the system to fully grasp the local stakeholder landscape and challenges faced.
Analysis and Developing the Nudge Assets
Decision architectures for Cervical Cancer were created, identifying points where eligible individuals make choices affecting screening uptake, such as booking and attending appointments. Hypotheses for each decision point were developed, suggesting behavioural 'nudges' to address them. This was supported by detailed analytics, demand forecasting, and visualisations to develop insights that combined national health data with other sources like population statistics.
Implementation/Testing and Skills Transfer
The analysis helped identify areas where the implementation could have the most significant impact, such as regions with socio-economic challenges and lower screening uptake. The cancer care team worked with a wide range of practices to find those eager to test the interventions with their patients. This led to selecting several GP practices as test sites, including control groups.

Outcome

Trials in Primary Care showed a positive impact of our solution. The nudge interventions developed are now live in 196 practices across an ICB region and continue to demonstrate success:
  • Year-on-year increase of 32.7% (483) in drop-in cervical screening clinic attendances.
  • Up to 88% response rate to screening invitations using behavioural science principles.
  • 27% increase in median cervical screening samples.
  • 24 - 32% increase in uptake in historical non-attenders (1000 extra screens per year in a typical PCN).
  • Circa 9% increase in colposcopy referrals

testimonial

Caja has truly exceeded our expectations with their commitment to co-develop and implement innovative Behavioural Science ‘nudges’ with our teams across South Yorkshire. Their interventions have not only made a significant impact on cancer early diagnosis and tackling inequalities; they have also paved the way for a ground-breaking advancement in building our capability and capacity through their ‘Nudge the Odds’ Academy. This extraordinary programme has empowered us to deliver tangible results for our communities and helped our teams think differently about how we engage with patients and communities. We have been delighted with Caja’s collaborative approach and cannot recommend them highly enough for their contributions to supporting Population Health.

Julia Jessop

Director

Get in Touch

We're here to help you transform your business. Whether you have questions about our services, need assistance with a project or want to explore potential collaborations, our team is ready to assist. Reach out to us through the contact details below, and let's start a conversation.